Split view: Miami beach with palm trees beside the Texas State Capitol with the lone star flag

Florida vs Texas: where do you keep more?

Key takeaways

  • On a $75,000 salary (2026), a single filer keeps $61,593 in both Florida and Texas — the income tax contest is a dead tie, because neither state charges one.
  • The real gap is property tax: Texas taxes homes at about 1.40% of value (7th highest in the US) versus 0.78% in Florida. On a $400,000 home, that's roughly $2,480 more a year in Texas.
  • But Florida hits back with homeowners insurance: the highest premiums in the nation, roughly $4,200–$6,000 a year vs $2,283–$4,200 in Texas. In most realistic scenarios, neither state is a clear winner once you price everything.
  • For renters, the difference mostly disappears: same take-home paycheck, and property taxes only reach you baked into rent.

It's the rivalry post of state tax debates: two giant Sun Belt states, both waving the "no income tax" flag, each claiming to be the low-tax champion. I ran the numbers expecting to find a winner. I didn't. Here's the honest breakdown, including the places where each state quietly makes its money back.

The short answer: it's a tie

Florida and Texas both charge $0 in state income tax on wages. Federal income tax and FICA are the same everywhere in the country. So for a single filer in 2026 on a $75,000 salary, the take-home number is identical in Miami and Houston:

DeductionFloridaTexas
Federal income tax$7,670.00$7,670.00
State income tax$0.00$0.00
Social Security$4,650.00$4,650.00
Medicare$1,087.50$1,087.50
Total tax$13,407.50$13,407.50
Take-home pay$61,592.50$61,592.50

That's about $61,593 a year — roughly 82 cents of every dollar — in both states. If a headline ever tells you one of them beats the other on income tax, that headline is wrong. There is no contest here; the contest is everywhere else.

The identical paycheck math, line by line

Same salary, same federal return, same result. The $7,670 federal figure comes straight from the 2026 brackets (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32): subtract the $16,100 standard deduction for a single filer, leaving $58,900 taxable. Then 10% on the first $12,400 ($1,240), 12% on the next $38,000 ($4,560), and 22% on the remaining $8,500 ($1,870). Add them: $7,670.00, effective rate about 10.2%.

FICA is the same math in Tampa and Dallas: Social Security at 6.2% ($4,650 on $75,000) plus Medicare at 1.45% ($1,087.50) for a total of $5,737.50. Payroll tax doesn't respect state borders; it starts on dollar one.

One number worth pocketing: your marginal rate on the next dollar is 29.65% (22% federal + 7.65% FICA). A $5,000 raise anywhere in America — Florida, Texas, or anywhere else — puts about $3,518 in your pocket. The state you live in changes none of this. What changes is everything below.

What each paycheck looks like (same in both states)

Take-home on $75,000 (single filer) by pay frequency — valid in Florida and Texas alike:

Pay frequencyGrossTake-home
Monthly (12)$6,250.00$5,132.71
Biweekly (26)$2,884.62$2,368.94
Weekly (52)$1,442.31$1,184.47

Biweekly workers: $2,368.94 every other Friday, whether your office is in Orlando or Austin. Keep that number; it's the baseline for everything that follows.

Where they actually differ: property tax

States without income taxes don't run on air. They make it up somewhere, and for Texas that somewhere is your house. The Tax Foundation's 2026 ranking puts Texas's effective property tax rate at about 1.40% of home value — 7th highest in the nation. Florida sits at about 0.78%, squarely in the middle of the pack. The reason is no mystery: Texas has no income tax and no help from tourism or mineral severance revenue, so property carries the load. Florida leans on its tourist economy instead.

What that means on a $400,000 home:

FloridaTexas
Effective property tax rate~0.78%~1.40%
Annual bill on a $400,000 home~$3,120~$5,600
Monthly differenceTexas costs ~$207/month more

That $207 a month is real money — over a decade it's roughly $25,000. Rates also vary wildly by county: Austin and Houston-area counties run hotter than the statewide average, while rural Texas can run cooler. And both states offer homestead exemptions that trim the bill for owner-occupied homes, so this is a before-exemption comparison. Still, directionally it's solid: Texas homeowners pay meaningfully more property tax than Florida homeowners on the same house.

Florida's hidden cost: homeowners insurance

Here is where the Florida story gets its asterisk. Florida has the highest homeowners insurance premiums in the country — averaging roughly $4,200 to $6,000 a year depending on the property and location — while Texas averages about $2,283 to $4,200. Hurricanes and a long history of insurance litigation are the reasons; Florida accounts for a wildly disproportionate share of US homeowners insurance lawsuits relative to its policy count, and insurers have priced that in.

On a comparable home, a Floridian can pay $2,000 to $3,000 more per year for insurance than a Texan — which erases most of Florida's property tax edge. Run the combined ownership math on that same $400,000 home:

Annual ownership costFloridaTexas
Property tax (~rates above)~$3,120~$5,600
Homeowners insurance (typical range)~$5,100~$3,200
Combined, roughly~$8,220~$8,800

Using midpoints, Florida lands around $580 a year cheaper — a real edge, but a modest one, and the exact result swings with the county, the home, and the carrier. My honest take: neither state wins this category by a margin worth choosing a life over. Get actual quotes for your specific zip code before deciding anything.

Sales tax, homestead exemptions, and the rest

A few smaller pieces, each honest and each small:

So who keeps more? An honest verdict

If you're a renter: nobody wins and nobody loses. Same paycheck, same $61,593, and the property tax question reaches you only as a line inside your rent. Pick the job, the city, and the life; the tax angle is noise.

If you're a homeowner: Florida usually comes out slightly ahead on the combined property-tax-plus-insurance math, Texas housing is cheaper to buy in the first place, and both beat nearly every income-tax state by thousands a year. In my opinion, the Florida-vs-Texas debate is mostly people arguing about the wrong line of the budget. The paycheck is identical. The house is where the fight is — and it's a much closer fight than the internet makes it sound.

Compare all 50 states →

Run your own numbers — any salary, any state:

Try the Take-Home Pay Calculator →

Last updated: October 2026. Income figures are 2026 estimates computed from IRS federal tax tables (Rev. Proc. 2025-32) and FICA rates — not tax advice. Property tax effective rates are the Tax Foundation's 2026 state rankings (Texas ~1.40%, Florida ~0.78%); homeowners insurance ranges reflect 2026 industry averages. All figures assume a single filer, no pre-tax deductions, and owner-occupied homes before homestead exemptions. Filing status, deductions, county rates, and your actual insurance quotes will change your real costs. Consult a tax professional for your situation.

TH

By Jisan Md Mahmudul Hasan, Founder & Editor. Every income figure in this guide was computed from the 2026 federal tax tables (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32) and current FICA rates, then cross-checked against our own calculator engine. Property tax rates come from the Tax Foundation's 2026 state rankings. Last reviewed October 2026.

The bottom line

Florida vs Texas on income tax is a dead tie: $61,593 take-home on $75,000 in both states, because neither charges income tax and federal rules are identical. The real comparison is property tax (Texas ~1.40% vs Florida ~0.78%, roughly $2,480 a year apart on a $400,000 home) against homeowners insurance, where Florida's nation-highest premiums claw most of that back. For renters, the states are financially indistinguishable. For homeowners, Florida usually edges it — slightly.

Frequently asked questions

Is there really no income tax difference between Florida and Texas?

Correct. Neither state charges individual income tax on wages, so the income tax math is identical. On a $75,000 salary, a single filer in 2026 keeps about $61,593 in either state — after $7,670 federal income tax and $5,738 FICA. The federal tax and payroll tax are the same everywhere in the US.

Which state has higher property taxes, Texas or Florida?

Texas, by a wide margin. The Tax Foundation's 2026 state rankings put Texas's effective property tax rate at about 1.40% of home value — 7th highest in the nation — versus about 0.78% in Florida. On a $400,000 home that's roughly $5,600 a year in Texas versus $3,120 in Florida.

Does Florida's homeowners insurance wipe out its property tax advantage?

It can come close. Florida has the highest homeowners insurance premiums in the nation, averaging roughly $4,200 to $6,000 per year versus about $2,283 to $4,200 in Texas. On a comparable home, Floridians often pay $2,000 to $3,000 more per year for insurance, which eats most of the property tax savings.

Do renters pay less tax in Florida or Texas?

Income tax is a tie for renters too: $0 state income tax in both, same federal and FICA. Renters feel property taxes only indirectly, baked into rent, and landlords pass along insurance costs the same way — Florida's steep insurance premiums often show up in higher rents.

Should I move to Florida or Texas to pay less in taxes?

Don't decide on the income tax alone — there isn't one to decide between. Price out housing, property tax, homeowners insurance, and everyday costs for your specific situation. A renter in either state keeps the same paycheck; a homeowner's math depends on home value and insurance rates in the exact county.